SIBO, or small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, is a condition that I, Katie McKersie at Holistico, have dealt with myself in the past and see so often in my practice. But SIBO is never the whole picture, and it is not really a root cause in itself. It is what happens when a slow metabolism and slow gut motility let bacteria build up where they should not.
SIBO, or small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, is a condition that I, Katie McKersie at Holistico, have dealt with myself in the past and see so often in my practice. Small intestinal bacterial overgrowth is an overgrowth of bacteria in the small intestine due to a slow metabolism, and the majority of my clients suffering from skin conditions and/or IBS have SIBO present. That link makes sense when you remember that acne and eczema are internal issues, driven by what is happening in the gut and with hormones, blood sugar, stress and metabolism, not problems that start on the surface of the skin, so surface only fixes do not solve them. But SIBO is never the whole picture, and it is not really a root cause in itself. It is what happens when a slow metabolism and slow gut motility let bacteria build up where they should not. Keep reading to find out why that distinction matters, because it changes how you fix it. It is still a crucial step you need to address in your health journey.

What Is SIBO?
What is SIBO and what are the typical symptoms of SIBO?
SIBO stands for small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, and it occurs when there is a build up of either good and/or bad bacteria in the small intestine. PubMed: ACG Clinical Guideline on Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth The majority of our bacteria should always be living in our large intestine. When gut motility slows down, bacteria linger in the small intestine instead of moving through, and they ferment food that should have been digested and absorbed higher up. PubMed: Small Intestinal Bacterial Overgrowth (StatPearls) The two most prominent symptoms I see are excessive gas & chronic bloat.
In my practice, 9 times out of 10 if you have any kind of SIBO you will have one of those symptoms. However, I have had clients in the past that present with more of the secondary symptoms like;
-constipation
-diarrhea
-nutrient deficiencies (A, D, E, K)
-abdominal pain
-acne, rosacea & other skin conditions
-chronic fatigue
-anxiety and/or depression
-undigested food in stool
-dark under-eye circles
-rashes
-frequent nausea
-weight gain or weight loss
-acid reflux
-brain fog
-joint & bladder pain
Some of you may have heard of a less common condition called SIFO, which is small intestinal fungal overgrowth in the small intestine, and it can present with similar symptoms. SIFO usually occurs after SIBO has been left untreated for too long, the treatments are very similar, and I address both together. I do not treat SIBO or SIFO with antibiotics, but rather with herbal anti-bacterial and anti-fungal agents, built on supporting motility and metabolism, so the overgrowth does not keep repeating itself.
The 3 Types of SIBO
In my practice, there are 3 types of SIBO (not just two):
Hydrogen Dominant (phase 1)- This is the most common type and is associated more with diarrhea, abdominal pain and nutrient deficiencies
Hydrogen Sulfide Dominant (phase 1.5)- This is the most undiagnosed type and is associated with gas that has a rotten egg smell, histamine intolerance, joint pain as well as altering constipation & diarrhea
Methane Dominant (phase 2)- This is the least common type and is associated more with constipation, acid reflux, weight gain and brain fog
I like to explain these types in phases. It starts with FODMAPs (fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides, monosaccharides and polyols), which are short chain carbohydrates that are poorly absorbed by the small intestine. Cleveland Clinic: Low-FODMAP Diet When a slow metabolism is present, with low thyroid function and low stomach acid, these move through slowly and act as fuel for the bacteria in the small intestine. When bacteria ferment them, they produce hydrogen gas, which we call Hydrogen Dominant SIBO, or phase 1. Methane dominant SIBO is one step further, because the hydrogen gas will then feed the archaea (anaerobes), which will produce methane gas as a byproduct of that. This means that with methane dominant SIBO, it’s not necessarily the bacteria causing the high levels of methane gas. It’s more the methane producing archaea, which is why I like to call it phase 2. With hydrogen sulfide dominant SIBO, it’s important to know that this is a totally different gas than hydrogen. This is when sulfate reducers (bacteria) feed on the hydrogen gas produced by other bacteria to produce hydrogen sulfide gas, which is why I call it phase 1.5.
Why I Don’t Usually Find Breath Tests Beneficial
It can be hard to tell which type someone has, as all of these types are likely to present with bloat and/or abnormal gas. You also can have more than one type! The “gold standard” for testing SIBO is a breath test, but I don’t usually find these super beneficial, and here is why:
- They are expensive and not 100% accurate leading to false accusations and hope
- They usually are only testing hydrogen dominant or methane dominant SIBO. It will come back normal if you have hydrogen sulfide SIBO leaving many people confused and discouraged
- It does not tell us the root cause of why SIBO has occurred in the first place
- Many antibacterial agents used to eradicate SIBO are multi-faceted and will take care of all types present
- It is easy and fairly quick to identify SIBO through specific nutritional changes
The Tests I Run With My Clients
With my clients, I like to run both a GI Map and HTMA test while starting a metabolically supportive lower FODMAP protocol, because I want data, not guesses. Here is more info on these two tests. In our practice, we often see SIBO and leaky gut present when it comes to acne, which is why I test instead of guessing at which one it is. The GI Map will give us a lot of insight into whether SIBO is present, along with other pathogenic bacteria, parasites, fungus, viruses and more. It also tests immunity, detoxification, inflammation and mucosal barrier health, which are all critical pieces of the SIBO puzzle. The HTMA is a comprehensive mineral test to give us more insight into detoxification, adrenal function, nervous system balance and, most importantly, metabolic health. A poor metabolism at the cellular level is truly the root cause of SIBO, because low thyroid function and low stomach acid slow down your entire gastrointestinal tract, allowing this bacteria to ferment. SIBO is very much a motility issue. Cleveland Clinic: SIBO Your metabolism is what regulates your digestion, so if we do not optimize that, we are not fixing the root cause, we are just chasing the overgrowth around.
Why I Don’t Recommend the Low FODMAP Diet Long Term
This is exactly why I don’t recommend cutting all sugar and carbohydrates, or going on the typical “Low FODMAP” diet long term, because it is extremely suppressive to your metabolism. After all, how can you fix a body that is restricted from its primary source of fuel (glucose)? I have watched other people try the Low FODMAP diet, and although their SIBO symptoms are temporarily suppressed a lot of the time, they usually return with a vengeance, because the root cause was never addressed. Starving bacteria is not the same as fixing motility. Instead, I recommend doing a modified lower FODMAP approach temporarily, one that still includes a variety of micronutrients and a lot of metabolically supportive foods: easy to digest, nutrient dense, and enough of them, eaten regularly. This does not involve cutting out any macro, but you do need to be super strategic with your nutritional choices. For example, I find raw honey and sweet potatoes will feed SIBO, whereas pure maple syrup and white potatoes will not. Usually within a couple of weeks of this modified approach, many of my clients feel a massive relief of symptoms, which is how we know SIBO was present. Typically, it takes my clients and I about 8 to 12 weeks to clear it, and then we focus heavily on rebuilding their metabolism and restoring their mucosal barrier, so they do not run into digestive problems again in the future. This rebuilding stage is also when we recheck nutrient levels, because poor absorption can leave vitamin D low. NIH Office of Dietary Supplements: Vitamin D Fact Sheet If vitamin D does need supplementing, I choose a whole food form over a synthetic isolate, in the form the body actually recognizes, which is why I use and recommend Whole Food Vitamin D. My metabolically supportive lower FODMAP meal plans and grocery lists, coupled with specific binders, biofilm disruptors and targeted herbal anti-bacterial and anti-fungal agents, used on purpose, each with a clear job to do and only for as long as it is needed, have proven to be extremely effective over and over again. Although, some clients come to me in a very under-nourished and depleted state, so we need to take a step back first to balance their minerals and support their detoxification pathways as well as their immune system before doing any sort of eradication. Foundations first. I never recommend starting a SIBO or any gut protocol without first ensuring you are having at least one full bowel movement every single day, because we want to be excreting these toxins regularly, not re-circulating them.
SIBO and Acne
In my practice, SIBO and acne are strongly connected, because an overgrown, inflamed small intestine drives leaky gut, inflammation and hormone imbalance. I see oral antibiotics prescribed for acne temporarily clear skin by destroying bacteria, then acne and SIBO return with a vengeance, which is why I use an herbal approach instead. In my practice, women with SIBO usually have an imbalance in the estrobolome, the gut bacteria that metabolize estrogen and produce beta-glucuronidase, the enzyme that turns estrogens into their active forms and can push free estrogen too high when dysbiosis is present. We work on restoring metabolic and gut health so your body can digest food properly, produce the lactase enzyme and tolerate high quality dairy again, and use glucose, the primary fuel for our cells, instead of removing dairy and sugar as a band-aid. Acne is an internal issue, not a surface problem, and skincare has minimal effect on fixing it.
If any of this has resonated with you, join my program, The Acne Solution where I walk you through a SIBO protocol to clear it, and then teach you the foundational pieces, metabolism, motility, minerals, and regular meals, to prevent SIBO in the future. This program is very beneficial and valuable even if you don’t suffer with acne, because the gut and the skin are not separate stories. Many women have been diagnosed with IBS and didn’t even realize they had SIBO. Here is what other women like you have been saying:
“Katie is by far the best nutritionist I have ever worked with and I can honestly say I have worked with many of them” says Chloe Lapenat.
“Katie taught me how to get rid of my bloating for good. I no longer see blood in my stool and I don’t vomit mucus every morning” says Stefanie Dubois.
“I have suffered from celiac disease for years and always assumed it would be something I lived with for the rest of my life. Katie looked at the big picture to figure out the root causes of my issues instead of fixing it with a band-aid approach” says Julia Somerville.
“I have dealt with brutal stomach pain, heartburn and bloating for years and all I was ever told is that I have IBS. I didn’t know I could possibly have H Pylori and SIBO until I found Katie” says Sylvia Martin.
“After a few months I saw drastic improvements in my skin that I never thought I could achieve without medication” says Jessica Garcia.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is SIBO?
SIBO stands for small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, and it occurs when there is a build up of either good and/or bad bacteria in the small intestine. The majority of our bacteria should always be living in our large intestine. When gut motility slows down, bacteria linger in the small intestine instead of moving through, and they ferment food that should have been digested and absorbed higher up. The two most prominent symptoms I see are excessive gas & chronic bloat.
Should you follow a low FODMAP diet for SIBO?
I have watched other people try the Low FODMAP diet, and although their SIBO symptoms are temporarily suppressed a lot of the time, they usually return with a vengeance, because the root cause was never addressed. Starving bacteria is not the same as fixing motility. Instead, I recommend doing a modified lower FODMAP approach temporarily, one that still includes a variety of micronutrients and a lot of metabolically supportive foods: easy to digest, nutrient dense, and enough of them, eaten regularly.
How are SIBO and acne connected?
In my practice, SIBO and acne are strongly connected, because an overgrown, inflamed small intestine drives leaky gut, inflammation and hormone imbalance. I see oral antibiotics prescribed for acne temporarily clear skin by destroying bacteria, then acne and SIBO return with a vengeance, which is why I use an herbal approach instead. Acne is an internal issue, not a surface problem, and skincare has minimal effect on fixing it.